When maintaining your landscaping, one of the most important projects you’ll do in the spring is mulching. People often ask if they should remove mulch from the previous year before putting down a fresh layer. Surprisingly, many gardeners answer this question with a resounding “no!”.
As a passionate gardener, I use mulch liberally to suppress weeds, retain moisture, and protect my plants year-round. But when spring rolls around, I’m always unsure if I should remove last year’s mulch before adding fresh stuff. Can you just lay new mulch on top of old? Or does the existing layer need to go?
Through trial and error, I’ve learned you can often add new mulch to old without removing it But there are some important factors to consider, which I’ll outline in this article Follow these mulching best practices and you’ll keep your garden happily mulched.
Should You Remove Old Mulch Before Adding New?
There’s no definitive rule that old mulch must be removed before topping up The key is assessing the existing mulch layer first.
Here are some things to consider:
-
Thickness – If you already have 2-3 inches of mulch in place, no need to add more. Rake to refresh.
-
Matted Areas – Fluff up any matted spots and refresh thin areas.
-
Rotting & Decomposition – Some breakdown is good, but remove excessively rotted mulch.
-
Weeds & Grass – Pull any weeds and rake out old grass clippings.
-
Pest Issues – Discard mulch with fungus, pests, or severe mould problems.
As long as the current mulch layer isn’t causing major issues, it’s fine to top up. But a little maintenance first never hurts.
Freshening Up Old Mulch Before Topping Up
Here are some easy ways to spruce up old mulch before adding the new stuff:
-
Rake to break up any matted areas and levellow spots.
-
Fluff with a garden fork to improve drainage and airflow.
-
Remove excessive thatch and seriously decayed mulch.
-
Pull Weeds & Grass so they don’t reseed into fresh mulch.
-
Let Things Dry Out if old mulch retains too much moisture.
-
Treat any Pest Issues like heavy mould before adding new mulch.
Taking a little time to freshen up the old stuff will provide a clean foundation for your fresh mulch layers.
How Much Mulch Can You Add on Top?
When topping up old mulch, aim for these optimal depths:
- 2-3 inches over bare soil
- 1-2 inches over existing mulch
Too little and weeds sneak through. Too much can suffocate plant roots.
Err on the lesser side if the old mulch is already 2-3 inches deep. Excessive mulch builds up over time and causes drainage issues.
If plants seem stressed by too much mulch, gently remove some around the base. Find the root flare and pull mulch a few inches away.
Which Type of Mulch is Best for Topping Up?
All mulch materials can be used to top up old layers, including:
- Shredded wood/bark chips
- Straw
- Pine needles
- Leaves
- Compost
- Pebbles or gravel
Use what you have on hand or continue with your existing mulch type for consistency. Organic mulches are best for annual topping up as they decompose each year.
If switching types, first remove some old mulch so depths aren’t radically different. For example, don’t top bark mulch with tons of fluffy straw.
Key Tips for Mulch Topping Up
Follow these best practices when adding new mulch over old:
- Assess old mulch first and refresh if needed
- Keep total depth 2-3 inches
- Pull back excess mulch from plant stems and trunks
- Top up thin spots and bare areas
- Spread new mulch evenly and smoothly
- Reapply annually to maintain optimal depth
Properly mulching helps every garden thrive. With a little yearly maintenance, you can refresh your decor while nourishing the soil. Simply evaluate the existing mulch, make any needed fixes, and go ahead and layer that fresh stuff right on top.
Special Offer for New Customers
Hurry! Offer Expires May 31, 2024
So, should you remove old mulch?
Expert green thumbs contend that getting rid of last year’s mulch is completely unnecessary. Mulch gradually breaks down, adding beneficial nutrients and other organic matter to the soil. Removing pre-existing mulch every year only ends up to be extra work and a needless expense.
Check to see how much mulch was left over from last year at the start of spring. This helps you to determine how much new product to buy. About two inches of mulch should cover flowerbeds, three inches of mulch should cover shrub beds, and four inches of mulch should cover tree stumps. If that amount already exists in your yard, it is not necessary to add new mulch. But if you’re only down to an inch, add another inch of new mulch on top of the old layer to keep it at the right level.
Sometimes, mulch can knit together and start to mat–shredded hardwood in particular. Matted mulch can hinder rain and sunlight from soaking through and feeding the plant roots beneath the soil. To prevent mats, removal is not the answer. Instead, fluff the mulch using a rake or cultivator and then add more mulch to the top. However, if the matted mulch has grown a fungus or mold, you should either use a fungicide to kill it or get rid of it completely, depending on how bad the damage is.
For in-depth answers about mulching or any other of your landscaping questions, call Cardinal Lawns today. We’re here to help your lawn look its best!.
Removing Old Mulch Before Adding New Mulch to Your Beds
FAQ
Should old mulch be removed before adding new?
How do you cover old mulch?
How to reapply mulch?
How often should mulch be replaced?