In the late 19th century, cities around the world faced a serious problem – what to do with all the horse manure filling up their streets As populations grew and cities expanded, the number of horses used for transportation soared In New York City alone, there were an estimated 100,000 horses producing nearly 2.5 million pounds of manure per day in 1900. In London, there were over 50,000 horses transporting people and goods around the city each day.
All this manure created major public health issues. It attracted huge numbers of flies that spread diseases like typhoid fever. The smell was overpowering. And perhaps most alarmingly, the mountains of manure were growing at an astounding rate.
The Crisis Reaches Breaking Point
In 1894, concerns about the horse manure problem reached fever pitch Writing in the Times of London, one writer estimated that within 50 years every street in London would be buried under 9 feet of manure. He predicted the city would be uninhabitable due to the stifling smells and disease-ridden streets
At an urban planning conference in 1898, delegates despaired over the lack of solutions. The conference broke up early because the scale of the manure problem seemed insurmountable. More horses meant more transportation, but also more manure. Cities were drowning in the stuff with no relief in sight.
The Automobile Provides an Unexpected Solution
Just as fears hit their peak that cities would soon be smothered in horse manure, the problem began to recede almost overnight. The invention and mass production of automobiles provided an unexpected rescue.
Within a few decades, cars began replacing horses as the main form of transportation in cities. The number of horses plummeted, and the mountains of manure quickly shrank. Over the early 20th century, streets cleared and cities became clean, livable places again.
What had seemed an inevitable crisis was solved through technological innovation. The intractable horse manure problem became a relic of the past.
Lasting Lessons
The horse manure crisis of 1894 provides an important lesson that remains relevant today. When faced with a seemingly unsolvable problem, it’s easy to extrapolate a disastrous future. But history shows even entrenched issues can be resolved through new technologies and forward-looking solutions.
As cities around the world grapple with challenges like pollution, traffic and housing shortages today, the horse manure crisis offers hope. With vision and innovation, cities can once again transform for the better, just as the automobile rescued cities from being smothered over a century ago.
The horse manure crisis is a classic example of how a difficulty that appears insoluble in the present can become irrelevant in the future. Rather than resignation, the story should inspire confidence that today’s urban problems contain the seeds of tomorrow’s solutions if we’re bold enough to find them.
The New York Horse Manure Crisis
- Globalization (S2 E6 – 56m 19s): Find out how energy, which is widely traded and helps move goods around the world, sped up globalization. Globalization has always been a goal in the past, but new types of energy made it possible.
- Culture S2 E5 – 54m 44s Culture and lively modern life go hand in hand. The energy of today has changed our style, music, and art. A lot of modern culture was paid for by rich industrialists who made a lot of money from energy. They used energy systems to spread culture all over the world.
- Entertainment S2 E4 – 57m 15s Entertainment affects and shows how we feel about energy. Popular music, movies, TV shows, and video games were made possible by modern energy, which changed our society. With climate control and modern lighting, energy has changed sports, and amusement parks help people learn about new energy technologies.
With WETA Passport, you can stream tens of thousands of hours of your favorite PBS and local shows whenever and wherever you want. Catch up on a single episode or binge-watch full seasons before they air on TV. You must have JavaScript enabled to use this form.
The Horse Manure Crisis of 1894 – The REAL Reason Cars Took Over
FAQ
What was the manure problem of 1894?
What was the horse manure crisis in the 1890s?
What was the horse manure crisis in New York City?
Where did the Great manure Crisis of 1984 happen?
How many feet of manure were buried in London in 1894?
The London Times predicted in 1894 that in 50 years time, every street in London would be buried under nine feet of manure. By the late 1800s, large cities all around the world were “drowning in horse manure”. In order for these cities to function, they were dependent on thousands of horses for the transport of both people and goods.
What was the great horse manure crisis of 1894?
The great horse manure crisis of 1894 refers to the idea that the greatest obstacle to urban development at the turn of the century was the difficulty of removing horse manure from the streets. More broadly, it is an analogy for supposedly insuperable extrapolated problems being rendered moot by the introduction of new technologies.
Why was the great horse manure crisis important?
In conclusion, the Great Horse Manure Crisis of 1894 serves as a stark reminder of the unforeseen consequences of rapid urbanization and technological advancements. The crisis highlighted the need for innovative solutions and the importance of considering long-term sustainability in urban planning.
How did technology help solve the horse manure crisis?
During the horse manure crisis of 1894, technological innovations played a crucial role in finding solutions to the mounting problem. One such innovation was the development of the horse-drawn street sweeper, which helped to alleviate the accumulation of manure on city streets.
Why was horse manure a problem in the 19th century?
The dominance of horse transportation in the 19th century led to the accumulation of massive amounts of horse manure in urban areas. The horse manure crisis posed significant public health concerns and had a detrimental impact on the environment.
How did the horse manure crisis affect cities?
The horse manure crisis had a significant environmental impact on cities. As the number of horses increased, so did the amount of manure they produced. This led to pollution of the streets and waterways, creating unpleasant odors and unsanitary conditions.