Knowing when to do the things that will keep your lawn looking its best is a big part of taking good care of it. Picking the right time to scarify your lawn is important to make sure you do it right and don’t hurt it more than you need to. There’s no point in working hard to get rid of dead moss and thatch from your lawn only to make things worse in other ways that will hurt its long-term health and growth.
People love having a lush, healthy lawn, and regular upkeep is the only way to get it that way. Scarification is an important part of lawn care because it gets rid of thatch and other debris that has built up over time, making it easier for air, water, and nutrients to reach the grass, says Jonathan Ames, a lead designer at the online landscape design company Bacqyard.
We asked lawn care professionals when they thought was the best time to scarify their lawn and how often they thought it should be done.
A spring tine rake is a good tool for scarifying a lawn by hand (image credit: Alamy Stock Photo, Graham Corney).
A beautiful, lush green lawn is the pride and joy of many homeowners But maintaining a healthy lawn does take some work One of the key tasks is scarifying, which removes moss, thatch and debris to allow proper air, water and nutrient flow to the grass roots. But how often should you scarify your lawn? I’ll examine the factors that determine the ideal frequency.
What is Lawn Scarification?
Scarifying, sometimes called dethatching, is the process of removing the thatch layer that builds up on lawns over time. Thatch is made up of dead grass stems, leaves and roots along with moss If allowed to become too thick, thatch blocks air, water and fertilizer from reaching the soil and grass roots
Scarifying rips up and removes this thatch layer with either a mechanical scarifier machine or a spring-tined rake. This leaves the lawn looking rough and uneven initially, but allows the grass to grow back thicker and healthier.
When to Scarify Your Lawn
The best times for scarifying are spring and autumn. In spring, scarifying clears away debris from winter so sun, air and nutrients can get down to the grass roots to promote lush regrowth. Autumn scarifying improves winter drainage and clears moss before it takes hold in cooler temperatures.
Aim for mild days with no heavy rain or heat forecast. Don’t scarify a totally wet or bone dry lawn, which can damage the turf. Slightly moist soil is ideal.
For cool season grasses like fescue and bluegrass, focus on early spring and fall scarifying. Warm season grasses like Bermuda and zoysia can be scarified anytime during spring and summer while actively growing. Avoid scarifying these grasses in fall right before winter dormancy.
How Often Should You Scarify?
Scarify your lawn at least once per year, either spring or autumn. But several factors affect ideal frequency:
-
Lawn Age – Don’t scarify a brand new lawn for at least one year after seeding or turfing to avoid damage while establishing.
-
Grass Type – More vigorous grasses like Bermuda tolerate more frequent scarifying than delicate types like fescue.
-
Soil Type – Heavy clay soils tend to need more scarifying to prevent thatch buildup.
-
Lawn Usage – High foot traffic causes faster thatch buildup, needing more scarifying.
-
Weather – Wet, humid climates cause more moss requiring additional scarifying.
-
Shade – Shaded areas often need extra spring scarifying to allow thicker regrowth.
As a general guide:
-
New Lawns – Once a year after establishing.
-
Delicate Grasses – Once a year in early spring or autumn.
-
Vigorous Grasses – Twice a year in spring and autumn.
-
High Use Lawns – Twice a year, early spring and autumn.
-
Wet Climates – Twice a year to control moss.
-
Heavy Soils – Twice a year to prevent thatch buildup.
Signs Your Lawn Needs Scarifying
Watch for these signs your lawn needs scarifying:
-
Thatch layer over 1/2 inch thick. Can check by lifting a corner of turf.
-
Lawn has excessive moss growth.
-
Puddles form on lawn and take over 24 hours to drain.
-
Lawn feels spongy underfoot.
-
Grass roots don’t extend deeper than 1 inch.
-
Poor lawn growth, thinning or bare patches.
-
Grass lays over flat and resists standing back up when mowed.
-
Push a screwdriver into lawn and it penetrates thatch easily before resistance from soil.
Dethatching vs Scarifying
While often used interchangeably, dethatching and scarifying are slightly different processes:
-
Scarifying uses stiff tines to rip out some live grass along with the thatch. Leaves lawn looking torn up temporarily. Best for heavy thatch removal.
-
Dethatching only removes dead material and avoids damaging live grass. Less aggressive, leaves lawn looking cleaner after. Good for routine seasonal thatch control.
So dethatching is less invasive and can be done more frequently such as 2-3 times per year. Use scarifying for less frequent, deep clean-ups of heavy thatch once per year.
Scarifying Tips
Follow these tips for successful lawn scarifying:
-
Mow lawn on lowest setting before scarifying to avoid blunting tines with long grass.
-
Remove debris immediately after scarifying so it doesn’t block sunlight and air flow.
-
Apply extra grass seed to bare patches a week after scarifying to thicken up lawn.
-
Adjust scarifier tine aggression based on lawn condition. Start gentle, getting more aggressive on subsequent passes if needed.
-
Make 2-3 passes over lawn at slightly different angles to ensure even scarifying.
-
Water lawn regularly for 2 weeks after scarifying to help grass regrow quickly.
-
Let lawn fully recover before heavy use or further treatment like fertilizing.
Should You Hire a Professional?
Scarifying is hard work, so many homeowners opt to hire a professional lawn care company. The benefits include:
-
Professionals have commercial power scarifiers that do the job faster and more efficiently.
-
They know exactly when and how to scarify for your specific lawn type and conditions.
-
Less heavy labor for you plus no machine investment.
-
A uniform finish across the entire lawn done properly.
-
Fertilizer and seeding applied after to aid regrowth.
If you don’t mind some elbow grease and have a small, simple lawn, DIY scarifying can work well. But for larger or complex lawns, hiring a pro takes the hassle out of this important seasonal chore.
Scarifying is vital for a lush, healthy lawn but should be done at the right time and interval. While specific conditions affect ideal frequency, plan to scarify at least once per year, either spring or fall. Watch for signs it’s needed more often, like heavy thatch buildup. Hiring a professional takes the hard work out of scarifying for a picture-perfect lawn.
What are the best weather conditions for scarifying a lawn?
Scarifying a lawn can also be best done at certain times of the year depending on the weather, so check the forecast to make sure you pick the right day. On most days, mild days are best because your lawn won’t be too hot and dry or too cold and wet.
Jonathan Ames from Bacqyard says to pick a day when the soil is just the right amount of wet or dry. If it’s too dry or too wet, the process won’t work as well and could even hurt the grass. Aim for a day with mild temperatures and no heavy rain or extreme heat, as these can be hard on the lawn and make it take longer to recover.
You don’t want to scarify your lawn if it’s completely wet or dry. Instead, do it when it is just slightly moist, which is usually best achieved when the lawn gets watered around two days before scarifying it, says Jeremy Yamaguchi, CEO of Lawn Love. If the grass is noticeably wet or entirely dry, your efforts will likely cause much more damage than good.
When to scarify a lawn
Spring and fall are the best times to scarify your lawn. Gardening expert Tim Rumball says it’s best to do the job twice a year, even though it only needs to be done once a year.
Lawn sand can be used to kill moss before scarifying, if needed. Mow the grass, wait until the moss turns black, and then firmly rake out the dead moss and thatch, he says. This can be done by hand with a spring-tined lawn rake, but is hard work. Using an electric scarifier fitted with a rake roller makes it easy.
A spring tine rake, like this Bully Tools 24-Tine leaf and thatching rake from Amazon, would work if you want to do it by hand.
Tim Rumball was editor of Amateur Gardening magazine in the UK for 20 years. He is a keen grower of edibles and wrote a popular series called Grow, Cook and Eat. He is also known for his practical no-nonsense approach to gardening.
Ruth Hayes, a gardening expert for Homes & Gardens, is in agreement. Spring and fall are the best times to scarify a lawn. It gets rid of all the winter’s trash and dead plants in the spring. This gives the roots more light, air, fertilizer, and water, which helps the grass grow thick and green.
You can help your lawn drain better by scarifying it in the fall. This will help you avoid problems with waterlogging and soil compaction that can happen when it rains or melts snow.
Ruth is the gardening editor of Amateur Gardening magazine, the UKs oldest weekly magazine. She is horticulturally trained and has qualifications from the Royal Horticultural Society. Ruth’s job is to write about and take pictures of the gardening tasks that our readers should do every week and month. She also tests a lot of new gardening products that come out on the market. She often scarifies her lawn to remove the build up of moss and thatch.
Your most rigorous scarifying season is fall (usually September), as heavy raking can leave the soil exposed so you want to avoid the summer weeds, explains Carlos Real of Total Lawn.
On the other hand, light scarifying should be done in the spring, around April, when things start to get warmer. This way, your lawn will recover much faster, without having to deal with the heat and dryness of summer, which can slow grass growth.
Most people agree that the best times to scarify a lawn are in the spring and fall, but it will also depend on where you live and the type of grass you have. It’s important to know the difference between cool season and warm season grasses because they need slightly different care.
For cool-season grasses, early spring and early fall are great times to get out and scarify for thatch removal. For warm-season lawns, the spring through the summer is the best time, says Eric DeBoer, agronomist with Simple Lawn Solutions. You dont want to beat up your warm-season lawn in the fall just prior to entering winter dormancy, and you dont want to beat up your cool-season lawn in early summer prior to the onset of heat and drought stress.
Dethatching is another lawn care task that is completed at a similar time. Scarifying and dethatching are both ways to get rid of dead grass on your lawn, but they are not the same. Make sure you choose the right method for your lawn. ( credit: Paul Maguire/Alamy Stock Photo).
WHEN IS THE BEST TIME TO SCARIFY YOUR LAWN?
FAQ
What month should I scarify my lawn?
Is it better to aerate or scarify?
Is it better to dethatch or scarify?
How many times can you scarify a lawn?
How often should you scarify your lawn?
You should ideally scarify your lawn twice a year, but not when the ground is cold – it should be at 10°C or more. Equally, if the weather gets too hot, it’s best to postpone scarifying to prevent the lawn from drying out. Spring is the best time of year to scarify a lawn.
When is the best time to scarify a lawn?
We put the questions to lawn care experts to get their top timing tips. A spring tine rake is a suitable tool ideal for manually scarifying a lawn ‘Spring and fall are the best times to scarify your lawn. It’s a job that generally only needs doing once a year, but doing it twice a year can be beneficial,’ says gardening expert Tim Rumball.
Is March a good time to scarify your lawn?
Like October, many people believe that March is a good time to scarify. It’s too cold. Even if it’s been mild and sunny, the soil is still cold from the winter and there’s still a risk of frost. That said, late March is a good time to prepare your lawn for scarifying by applying moss killer.
How much grass should you Mow before scarifying?
‘Before you scarify you should mow your lawn to about 1in and collect any clippings,’ adds Carlos. ‘This may take numerous mows, as each time you mow you should not be cutting off more than a third of the grass, otherwise you risk putting your grass under too much pressure.’